Forums » Africa

PHASA.....What good are they?

    • 23 posts
    April 15, 2010 1:36 PM EDT

    As for a post above, I'm looking to get my hunting permits to get my animals "out of Africa". Since Cobus Roos isn't a member, they are not willing to help at all...even though the animals were taken legally. The problem is Mr. Roos is "too busy" to do anything...which is a joke to say the least. But PHASA and South Africa is general need to do more policing of their PH's and licenses........actions need to be made so a PH can loose his license to operate. Us United States hunters have enough problems as it is...and lazy PH's...should be the least of our problems!

    • 7 posts
    April 19, 2010 11:16 AM EDT
    Hi. Enysse, I amsorry to hear. Did you receive a copy of your PH register from Cobus? Which taxidermy did he hand your trophies in? You can mail me and I will try to help. hennie.sahunter@gmail.com
    • 9 posts
    May 4, 2010 10:27 AM EDT
    You should write to the Nature Department of the provinc he is registered in.They are supposed to act against such things
    as ever
    dave
    • 1 posts
    May 21, 2010 9:43 AM EDT
    I am sorry to hear that you had such an unfortunate experience from a PH in SA. I agree you should take this up with nature conservation in the province that he is registered as he will need to be registered with them in order to be a PH. They also do have a policy on code and conduct and will therefore step in I am sure.
    Good luck.
    • 23 posts
    May 21, 2010 1:17 PM EDT

    Thanks for all the nice replys, I must admit, I thought I knew all the in's and out's....I really knew nothing (lol). I have gone through great lengths now to figure out all the rules and regulations.

    The great thing about hunting with a PHASA registered PH, is if you have a problem, they are there in the background to sort the source of the problem out and help you get it corrected.

    I can tell you one thing....only hunt with a outfitter that hunts his land mainly. Don't hunt with a "Bakkie PH" (A Ph that hunts out of the back of his or her truck) or "Freelance PH", figure it out right away....and tell the "Freelance PH" to take a hike...they are not worth hunting with at all...unless you are just taking pictures....these PH's have nothing invested into the hunt and only around for the money. You will be luck as hell if you ever see your animals again after the hunt is done. Hunt permits and everything become a total nightmare and you will have bills and bad memories. DON'T DO IT

  • May 30, 2010 9:21 AM EDT

    Enysse I have read the saga of your lost trophies with some regret. I can see what has happened and yes it seems you were lied to by an unscrupulous Businessman/Outfitter/PH. The whole issue should not cause you to throw up your hands in despair though. If you know where the trophies are and they're still in a decent state then the Taxidermist should be able to make a plan to ship them to you.

    Regarding your comment above I must take some exception and i'd like to put the record straight here. Most PH's (who are not also outfitters) in South Africa are freelance to a large extent. They work for different outfitters. Some but not all are members of PHASA. Some but not all shoot from Bakkies, so do Outfitters and land owners as well. Freelance Ph's make almost no money to speak of and rely to a large extent on tips. They invest a lot of money in their equipment being Bakkies, Bullbar/winch systems, seatings and etc... The outfitter from whom you buy the hunt can run the hunt in two different ways 1) He can do the hunt himself 2) He can hire a PH to do it on his behalf. Regarding paperwork the duty of the Freelance PH is to fill out and sign an export register for the trophies that were shot under his command. The outfitter is to do all the rest, that being TOPS permits, collecting cheques and seeing that the paperwork (apart from the export register unless he's the PH for the hunt) are completed so the trophies can be exported unhindered.

    The problem you had while in South Africa refers to the Outfitter that also acted as your PH (at the time of your hunt he was not acting as a Freelance PH but was acting as your outfitter). I don't believe it is fair to tar Freelance PH'S with this brush as it is incorrect to do so.

    I hope that clears up some of the confusion around the issue and I hope you get your trophies, as I said in my opinion if you know where they are and they are in a decent state you should'nt have a problem.


    • 23 posts
    May 30, 2010 11:25 AM EDT
    Thanks for the reply huntdog, I think it's alright if you are a freelance guide and work for a number of outfitters....no problem there at all. And I have no problem with people hunting out of a bakkie. The problem I have is with the Freelance PH that brings his own client to hunt on outfitters or landowners property...mostly for tips. I have been told, it seems a lot, that there is no room for the Freelance PH and they wreck the outfitter/PH operations. Outfitters that have the land would just as soon rid the Freelance PH and eliminate the competition.....so clients would just deal straight with the Outfitter/PH that runs the land.

    Yes, the client may have to got to another landowners property to hunt all the animals on his or her list. But as long as its outfitter to outfitter talking all of the melodrama for the most part is taken out of the equation.

    The thing I've learned is competition for clients is very keen, in this economy and that you don't want to be caught in the middle of the competition.

    I would only recommend to hunt in Namibia or South Africa on a outfitter/ph's land or concession that he or she has control of...so you are staying at their lodge or tent camp, where they monitor and know where the animals are located and will take care to handle your permits properly and ensure your animals make it to the taxidermist.
  • May 30, 2010 11:52 AM EDT
    Enysse, if the Freelance PH brings his own client to the Outfitters property then regardless how anybody views the situation the PH is also the outfitter for the duration of that particular hunt. In South Africa an Outfitter needs to have met predetermined and stringent criteria before he can act as an outfitter (in all provinces except the Free State. In the Free State any PH can act as an outfitter without needing to meet criteria ather than a PH licence). If you hunted with somebody that sold you a hunt without meeting the required outfitter criteria then you have a right to lay a charge of fraud at any South African Police station against the person who sold you the hunt. That person will be prosecuted and sentenced to a fine or imprisonment for fraud!
    • 1 posts
    May 30, 2010 12:12 PM EDT
    enysse,
    I agree with hunterdogs comments above.
    It is not ok to tar all people with the same brush based on your one experience. Some of the best outfitters I know are freelance, and some of the worst outfitters I know are landowners. There are many landowners who give the hunting rights on their ranches out to single or multiple outfitters since they are not in the business of hunting themselves. To them it is a business arrangement. There are always bad apples, and even Phasa cannot always root them out.
    Your best redress is through the game department in the area you hunted.
    Send them a copy of the register that you signed and ask them to take action. You are also at liberty to deal directly with the taxidermist where your trophies were shipped.
    If there is a problem with the outfitter you chose, name them and shame them. The internet is far reaching. The hunting industry is small. Notify SCI, DSC and the Hunting Report and start working from there.
    I am really sorry you had this hassle and apologise on behalf of all us long established, good and reputable freelance outfitters out there who do not neccesarily belong to Phasa.
    Kind Regards,
    John
    • 23 posts
    May 30, 2010 12:25 PM EDT
    "If you hunted with somebody that sold you a hunt without meeting the required outfitter criteria then you have a right to lay a charge of fraud at any South African Police station against the person who sold you the hunt. That person will be prosecuted and sentenced to a fine or imprisonment for fraud! " , by Huntdog.

    That's where I ran into the problem at my last hunt....as was stated I was the idiot for trusting the guy.

    Huntdog, you are a true professional, I wish everyone had as much common sense as you. The problem, is even if you follow the rules....I saw a lot of tension between the Freelance PH/outfitters and the landowners, on a number of instances. There seemed to be a lot discussion on money issues, etc.

    I don't like tension on a hunting trip....vacations should be fun and exciting. That's why I recommended a hunt with a Outfitter/PH operation that owns the land or has a concession.
    • 23 posts
    May 30, 2010 12:34 PM EDT

    "There are many landowners who give the hunting rights on their ranches out to single or multiple outfitters since they are not in the business of hunting themselves. To them it is a business arrangement.", by SAsafaris.

    I can't disagree with your statement above. The hunting on those lands, is intense, not a quality hunt at all.

    My statements are being misunderstood.....Freelance Ph's are legal and they are skilled...no doubt about it. But having control of land and operations is the key to a really good hunt.

  • May 31, 2010 1:12 AM EDT
    Hi Enysse,
    In Limpopo province you as a freelance PH are not allowed to advertise hunts if you are not the owner of a Outfitter. Their are law in place that will protect the hunter in that regards. The Outfitter have a permit nr that must be on the inventation letter when he invate a client to come and hunt. Their are a lot of Outfitters that have hunting rights on diffrent conssesions and the hunt is of a high quality. If you are a good Outfitter you will make sure that the trophy's are available on such conssesions. That why it is importent to make sure that you know what animals you client wants to hunt before the time. But let this be a eye opener for all the Outfitters out their to stay with a 200% service attuded.
    Hunting greetingsd
    Benno
    • 23 posts
    May 31, 2010 10:12 AM EDT
    I had a bad last hunt. I guess I know what I'm looking for on the next hunt. There are a lot of great outfitters in Africa. Next time, I'll go with a very experience outfitter. Hopefully I can get back in the years to come.

    My posts haven't been to bad mouth South Africa PH's. There are a ton of great PH's in Africa. Where else can you go...and see great animals every trip for the most part. My posts where to warn people of the very small part of the bad outfitters out there.

    And I hope my posts, have made people, pick a quality taxidermist. You can't get by without a quality taxidermist or a dip and pack company. Do a lot of research....I love my taxidermist.
    • 2 posts
    May 31, 2010 9:14 PM EDT
    Hello Enysse, I have read all of the posts and I am sorry to hear that you had such a bad experience. One point I would like to make is that anyone planning a trip to Africa, or anywhere for that matter, should to check several refrences before booking a hunt. Any outfitter or booking agent should be able to supply you with a list of former clients to talk with while making your decision on such an expensive hunt. Everyone should take advantage of this opportunity to learn about the professionalism of the outfitter and PH's.

    I am a booing agent as well as a partner with the outfitter I work with in Africa. I have been doing this for the past 10 years and I only work with 1 outfitter. I personally check out all the new hunting areas that my partner aquires. My partner only hunts on ground that he owns or has EXCLUSIVE hunting rights. In situations where the outfitter does not have exclusive rights to the ground, there is often problems with the other outfitters and the land owner is generally made out to be the bad guy. I have seen in the past some of the things that you mentioned concerning tension between PH/outfitters and land owners. These can get ugly and from these experiences I know the importance of good relations between landowners and outfitters. All pricing is agreed upon before the hunting season and if there are any discrepancies they are handled behind the scenes and never in front of the paying client.

    I would follow the advise given by the outfitters in the previous posts. Start with the taxidermist and work back from there. I would also expose the bad PH/Outfitter as much as possible as advised. There are hundred if not thousands of outfitters in South Africa, but it is very small when it comes to issues like yours. I promise that the word will travel like wild fire and your "bad outfitter" will suffer in the end.
    • 10 posts
    November 3, 2010 2:15 PM EDT
    Check tis websit i has good info www.cowboyhunter.com
    • 39 posts
    November 26, 2010 10:40 AM EST
    KEEP US UDATED!
    • 23 posts
    November 26, 2010 11:01 AM EST
    There is nothing to report, Cobus Roos hasn't done the necessary paperwork, the taxidermy is collecting dust in South Africa and the Nature Conservation is too involved in all the Rhino poaching to do anything about it. It's just a sad story...very frustrating. PHASA won't do anything either....it's a culture thing.
    • 39 posts
    November 26, 2010 11:05 AM EST
    I think its time for you to get out and head south! Come and hunt corsican with me in jan, and I bet you will not think of SA for a long time!
    • 23 posts
    November 26, 2010 11:12 AM EST
    I hear you David, I would love to hunt audad or oryx down there sometime....axis deer would be great too. I used all my vacation time working on my house this year.

    But yes, I love your posts and would love to hunt down there sometime!
    • 110 posts
    November 26, 2010 8:18 PM EST
    Enysse,

    Am real sorry to hear that there is no action, its just too bad that you picked the wrong guy to hunt with.

    Folks this is why it pays to use a good booking agent, atleast you can try and twist his arm here in the states!

    Regards,

    Arjun
  • November 27, 2010 9:19 AM EST
    Enysse. Please post (on H networks) or e-mail me the Taxidermist or Nature Conservation office details who is in Possession of your Trophies. Let me see what the issue is from this side.
    • 2 posts
    November 29, 2010 5:55 AM EST
    Enysse,

    My friend, why did'nt you tell me you are having trouble getting your trophies back. Please send me a e-mail with all animals needed to be exported and I will sort it out for you. My e-mail adress is js@hartzviewsafaris.co.za.

    Talk to you soon and looking forward on helping you with this matter.

    Best regards,

    Jacques
    • 2 posts
    January 19, 2011 3:57 AM EST

    A bit late in the day to say so, but I agree whole-heartedly with your sentiments in this regard. It is hard enough for us as African Outfitters to recruit clients and when shoddy workmanship such as this happens it reflects badly on the rest of us!

    • 2 posts
    January 19, 2011 3:57 AM EST

    A bit late in the day to say so, but I agree whole-heartedly with your sentiments in this regard. It is hard enough for us as African Outfitters to recruit clients and when shoddy workmanship such as this happens it reflects badly on the rest of us!

    Phil and Kate de Kock

    Bosbok Safaris

    South Africa

    • 23 posts
    January 19, 2011 11:17 AM EST
    Thanks everyone for your kind words...it definitely has been a hard learned lesson. And a sour taste in the mouth!