Last night, CNBC aired a documentary called "Remington: Under Fire" an hour-long news piece purporting to show that Remington's venerable 700 series rifle had been unsafe since its introduction nearly six decades ago. Further, the program charged that Remington had not only known of the problem since the rifle's introduction, it had knowingly avoided fixing the problem.
Heady stuff, but no more impressive than Remington's equally blistering response. With letters to "Vendors, Retailers and Industry Partners" on October 12, Remington announced a conscious corporate decision not to cooperate in the CNBC investigation, despite having supplied the network with "a great deal of factual information and background materials, including the Model 700's decades long record of safety and reliability."
The memo promised that Remington would "respond accordingly once the program airs" and, true to that promise, Remington has launched an all-out response. The first phase, a website that gives the company's initial response wastes no time in attacking the credibility of CNBC reporter Scott Cohn and the various experts making the claims against Remington. Cohn was an easy target, uneasily holding a Remington 700 in his opening standups and later, holding the rifle, bolt closed, with his finger on the trigger. So, too, was expert witness Jack Belk, with Remington's website showing excerpts of a deposition in which Belk, as an expert witness for the plaintiff, admitted he couldn't get the rifle to replicate the accidental discharge claimed in that lawsuit.
Again, high-powered responsiveness. Again, indicative of just how high the stakes are in such an instance. With high-powered publicists, attorneys and public relations agencies obviously in the mix, the spin levels at this point are huge. That's why there's no "instant analysis" in today's edition. This is a story that has potential repercussions across an entire industry, and certainly inside one of the companies that now comprise the largest American firearms company.
CNBC is running excerpts of their program on their website at: www.cnbc.com/id/39554936) . Remington's official response page is http://remington700.tv.
Journalists should talk to people on both sides of the fence before presenting a story if they are to be credible. It's clear to people who are used to using firearms that this is all BS of the highest order. I am sure Model 700s have been fired accidentaly but that's probably solely user error and not mechanical issues. The first and foremost rule of safe gun handling is to never point a gun at something you do not want to kill or point a gun in an unsafe direction regardless of whether the gun is loaded or unloaded.
In all the stories that aired where people got shot by accident, obviously this most important rule was broken. I so often hear of stories where a gun was fired off when cleaning it. The first thing you are supposed to do is unload the gun before cleaning it. Any mechanical item can fail, but that's where user accountability comes into play.
As it is trigger pulls have been set to ridiculous high levels I wonder what this will bring going forward.