Forums » Relating to Hunting and Fishing

Hunters Exchange Fire Over What's Fair Game

    • 110 posts
    October 18, 2010 1:58 PM EDT

    online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704518104575546253717892686.html

    The Wall street journal article asks what is fair in terms of hunting behind a fence. It is a hotly debated subject, but the bottom line is that there seems to be more and more of it around - i.e. hunting on a preserve. I feel that people who hunt regularly at these places have no real experience of hunting wild game and are frankly loosing out on the real experience of the hunt. I guess to each his own!

    • 39 posts
    October 18, 2010 10:35 PM EDT
    If there was a "catch all answer" I would give it, we've already discussed what a "preserve" means what "free range" means but I know a lot of great hunters and guides who routinely hunt preserves with the same results and challenges as any other hunt, but I dont think they or I am missing out on any experience.
    I like many other hunters and guides have hunted all over, and when done right, under the right circumstances and the right conditions, then its fair to say that its left up to opinions.
    Does a deer on a given amount of land say 2,000 acres have the same opportunity to hide, breed, live, die and flourish as does an unfenced deer, Yes, but then there's no comparison to a high mountain hunt for big horn, or is there?
    Hunters, guides, agents, or whatever you consider yourself to be in regards to the outdoors should ultimatly decided in their hearts if a given ranch, preserve,estate or free range hunt is right.
    DC
    • 52 posts
    October 20, 2010 9:28 AM EDT
    I think that I agree with Arjun in that people who hunt on preserves miss out on the real experience. I know a fellow who gets the photos of the deer emailed to him before he goes out and kills it on the given day. He knows how many inches it is and how many hairs it has on its head. So that's his choice, but no one can say that it is the same as hunting a wild deer, even if it in your backyard or a small plot of urban land.

    I guess no one is right or wrong its a question of choice. A lot of it depends upon the size of the place. Sure if you hunt a huge place like they have down in TX, thats as fair as can be, but if you shoot a 500" elk in a paddock like a farm cow, I ask where is the fun.