Forums » Small Bores

6.5 x 54mm Mannlichter "inaccuracy"!

    • 2 posts
    September 27, 2010 6:42 AM EDT

    Hi Guys

    I inherited a 6.5 Mannlichter Schonauer a few years back. The barrel was shot out and the stock in very bad condition. Due to limited finances I replaced the barrel with a Musgrave barrel and had a new stock built. The original ammo in 160gr RWS were very accurate but I only had a few and they were way to expensive to import (I live in SA) from Europe. The obvious solution was to reload. I tried for about 3 years to get and accurate 120gr and 140gr load as I wanted a slightly flatter trajectory than with the 160's. I acheived an "acceptable" load with the 120's and shot many antelope with the rifle but still not MOA. The rifle tended to throw the 3rd bullet and also seemed to project the bullet in a big circle as if you set it at 100m it would be shoot left at distances less than 100 and right a distances over 100. I'm used to pinpoint accuracy with my 270 so have never been at ease with the Mannlichter's accuracy. All the articles I've read rant and rave about this rifles accuracy which I have yet to see. I eventually decided to order 160gr RWS bullets as I thought the slower factory loads and longer bullets would stabilise the bullet and give me the accuracy I want. Needless to say the reason I'm writing this is because I still am not getting consistency and am starting to consider that I bought a "dud" barrel from Musgrave. Does anyone know if there is a way you can have your barrel checked or has any reloading ideas to try get consistent accuracy? Any help will be appreciated as I've been trying for about 10 seasons now to get an accurate load.

    • 52 posts
    September 27, 2010 8:42 AM EDT
    Hello Garry,

    I have worked up an accurate load (<1" groups at 100 yards) in my 6.5ms. The load in my rifle is 160 grain Hornady round nose infront of 40.5 grains of IMR 4350 - you will have to figure out which Somchem powder matches it I guess. Those old guns have a lot of issues, but with a new barrel should be better in theory! Bedding may also be an issue.

    Good luck

    J
    • 2 posts
    September 30, 2010 7:56 AM EDT

    Thanks Hitman. Yes I think I need to go have the bedding looked at. I'll do a powder comparison and see how close our loads are.

    • 2 posts
    October 14, 2010 10:30 PM EDT
    Hi Garry,
    I also own a 6.5 x 54 MS. With the new barrel, you may wish to check the actual bore size and also consider recrowning the muzzle. The twist should be at least 1 in 9 to stabilize the bullets you intend to use. I use my 1903 MS with iron sights often to whack pigs at a relatively close range so pinpoint accuracy is not important.

    When proper brass was difficult to come by, I used 6.5 x 52 Carcano brass and resized them. The necks were a hair short but did not affect function or relative accuracy.

    Geoff
    • 8 posts
    June 15, 2011 11:26 PM EDT
    I have a 6.5X54MS and sold a beautiful sporter last years as well. The first issue is that the original MS rifles had a .268 caliber & not .264. Slug your barrel & check this. Secondly the Musgrave barrel crown may be damaged by using steel cleaning rods which would cause damage to the muzzle are and cause the bullet to spray. I would suggest taht you slug you barrel full length by driving a lead slug right through and then also just the first 1/2 inch of the front of the barrel and then the first 1 " of the back end near the chamber. Compare the slugs to see if you can notice any obvious anomalies.