Too Much Hollywood in Hunting Shows

  • Hi all,

    Just writing this to vent a little bit, I guess. I finished watching another hunting program on TV that made me grit my teeth. I'm beginning to think that the majority of the "pros" are ignorant and arrogant with regards to the hunt. By "pros" I mean the ones who produce their own TV programs regarding the hunt.

    I seldom encounter episodes that show "true", unadulterated hunts, where the host does little to no acting and truly knows what they are talking about. I realize that a certain amount needs to take place in order to make it able to be viewed as a program, but many are just nauseating in the amount of staged scenes and lack of credible information.

    How many of you have continued to whisper to someone after the animal has expired several hundred yards or meters away? How many of you have ever said that you made a good shot when it is obvious that the hit was not fatal. How many of you have shot an animal in the early morning, and after having said that it was a good shot and the animal did not travel far, come upon the animal well after dark?

    I have spoken with a personal friend, who guides hunts in Colorado for elk and mule deer, that  told me one of his "pro" clients asked him to shoot an elk on camera because the "pro" client had missed on multiple opportunities. They just needed the footage and would edit him out when making the program. This client has had TV programs for years and is a so-called expert in the industry. Obviously, anyone who is worth their salt would not need anyone to "kill an animal for footage" for their programming needs. My friend denied the request, citing that it was unethical, and also illegal.

    I feel that it would be THE job to have, to travel to parts known and unknown, in pursuit of anything, and get paid to do it. It is just nauseating to think that there are individuals who do this for a living and do not have the credentials or desire to live up to their name or image, and make a farce out of what I (and many) hold true....

    Thanks for letting me rant and rave for a moment....

    Gary 

8 comments
  • haystack
    haystack after some thought i must digress some we do need these people what ever our personal feeling. if we let personal feeling get between us all hunters suffer. in fighting must stop. it is the sort of thing that the anti's feed off of. and i'm...  more
    May 27, 2009
  • SAHunter
    SAHunter Gary, I feel like you a lot of times. Some are not so bad, whilst others are bad. I think we just need to filter out those that we don't like, and not watch them. That way our souls can rest ;-)
    May 27, 2009
  • SteveThompson
    SteveThompson Some of those shows are like watching a train wreck. A few are just ok. One thing for sure - if you cant sleep at night, just put on the outdoor channel...
    May 27, 2009
  • deerstalker
    deerstalker I have seen Canada in the Rough, and I like it. I like The Best and Worst of Tred Barta, Elk Country Journal, and a few of the others. Not bad mouthing all of them, but most of them suck. I agree with Luke in saying that they wouldn't be able to...  more
    May 27, 2009