The right to self-defense ?

  •  

    Keep the right to self-defence
    When two thieves broke into his jewelry store and put a gun to his wife's head, Dennis Galloway fought back. The Port Alberni resident fetched a handgun and opened fire. One of the intruders was wounded; the other escaped unharmed.
    The incident happened a year ago, but Galloway's actions remain a source of controversy. The man he injured is now able to speak with police and details of the shootout have polarized the community.
    To many, Galloway is a hero. People have come into the store to shake his hand. But others see his actions as a threat to public safety.
    Even the authorities were split on the matter. The local RCMP detachment wanted Galloway charged with unsafe use of a firearm. However the Crown prosecutor declined and no action was taken.
    So where does this leave us? Is Galloway a courageous husband who stood his ground or a dangerous vigilante who took the law into his own hands?
    Unfortunately, the Canadian justice system is less than clear on this question. Two other cases in progress make that painfully obvious.
    In Toronto, storekeepers apprehended a man who had been stealing from their shop. Surveillance cameras show the man taking goods from their sidewalk displays and riding away on a bicycle.
    When he returned an hour later, the owner and two employees gave chase. They caught him, tied him up and held him until police arrived.
    There is no question they got the right man. He later pleaded guilty. But criminal proceedings are also going forward against the storekeepers. They've been charged with kidnapping, forcible confinement and carrying a concealed weapon (one of them had a box cutter on his belt). If convicted on all charges, they could face life in prison.
    In Stettler, Alta., a rancher tried to apprehend a thief who was making off with an ATV. It's alleged the crook had earlier stolen one of the farm trucks. As he was making good his escape, the rancher fired a shotgun after him. The man suffered no life-threatening injuries.
    As with the Toronto case, charges have been filed against the property owner. He faces seven criminal counts, including assault, criminal negligence causing bodily harm and discharging a firearm.
    Set aside what looks like prosecutorial overkill in both of these cases. The charge sheets appear excessive.
    But where does self-defence begin and end? The authorities in Stettler argue that since the alleged robber was unarmed, the use of a shotgun was unwarranted.
    The case against the storekeepers rests on a different distinction. The man they apprehended wasn't caught in the act. He had allegedly stashed the loot stolen earlier and was returning for a second helping. According to the Crown prosecutor, that nullifies any right his victims had to detain him.
    Let's agree that when force is needed, we would prefer to see it exercised by a trained police officer. But there is a common factor in each of these cases.
    For different reasons, none of the victims felt they could count on police assistance. Dennis Galloway had only seconds to save himself and his wife. There was no time to dial 911.
    The shoplifter in Toronto has been stealing from local businesses for more than 30 years. Store owners say they have no choice but to protect themselves.
    And remote farm buildings in rural Alberta are easy pickings. It might be a long way to the nearest RCMP detachment.
    None of these considerations justify excessive use of force. But they could establish grounds for self-defence.
    The desire of law enforcement agencies to protect us is admirable. But there might be occasions when their help is not at hand. In these exceptional situations, self-defence remains an important right.