44-40 for bison?????

  • I would like to know if a 44-40 will have the power to take a bison. I have a winchester lever action and don't want to buy a 45-70. I want to keep as close to traditional. Bob
6 comments
  • DavidC729
    DavidC729 Bob, why take the risk? In my opinion the 44-40 is not suited for Bison under any circumstance, i appreciate you wanting to stay as traditional as possible, but by doing this you're raising the possibilities ten fold for something going wrong, and when...  more
    May 29, 2009
  • moosemachine
    moosemachine A bison is very difficult animal to kill, the kill zone is low and they are incredibly tough. I was with a friend about 10 yrs past when he took a bison in our area with my 338 mag with 270 gr spears bullets and it took 5 shoots to down the animal. You...  more
    May 29, 2009
  • danonorth
    danonorth At close range it would do the job and may take more than one shot. A 45-70 is also very traditional thow I have had both sold the 44-40 but would never part with my 45-70, it is a buffalo hunter ( allthow I have never hunted buff, would love to) 1885...  more
    May 30, 2009
  • JonnyM93
    JonnyM93 I would have to agree with David i wouldn't take that risk using the 44-40 i would use a 300win or bigger, I just look at the size of the Bison and compared to water buffalo and they are close to the same size and guides say use a 300 and bigger as...  more
    May 30, 2009