I would like to know if a 44-40 will have the power to take a bison. I have a winchester lever action and don't want to buy a 45-70. I want to keep as close to traditional. Bob
DavidC729Bob, why take the risk? In my opinion the 44-40 is not suited for Bison under any circumstance, i appreciate you wanting to stay as traditional as possible, but by doing this you're raising the possibilities ten fold for something going wrong, and when... moreBob, why take the risk? In my opinion the 44-40 is not suited for Bison under any circumstance, i appreciate you wanting to stay as traditional as possible, but by doing this you're raising the possibilities ten fold for something going wrong, and when that happens someone could get hurt, or your Bison is running around wounded looking for the source of the hole in his body! This makes guides nervous, I;ve seen it too many times, Bob i think you should either make the effort to buy a more suitable caliber or borrow one from a friend. At the end of the day everyone wants to go home safe with good memories of a hunt well done. DC less
May 29, 2009
moosemachineA bison is very difficult animal to kill, the kill zone is low and they are incredibly tough. I was with a friend about 10 yrs past when he took a bison in our area with my 338 mag with 270 gr spears bullets and it took 5 shoots to down the animal. You... moreA bison is very difficult animal to kill, the kill zone is low and they are incredibly tough. I was with a friend about 10 yrs past when he took a bison in our area with my 338 mag with 270 gr spears bullets and it took 5 shoots to down the animal. You want a gun with lots of knock down power.
May 29, 2009
danonorthAt close range it would do the job and may take more than one shot. A 45-70 is also very traditional thow I have had both sold the 44-40 but would never part with my 45-70, it is a buffalo hunter ( allthow I have never hunted buff, would love to) 1885... moreAt close range it would do the job and may take more than one shot. A 45-70 is also very traditional thow I have had both sold the 44-40 but would never part with my 45-70, it is a buffalo hunter ( allthow I have never hunted buff, would love to) 1885 uberti highwall.The right loads in a 44-40 can be good with the heavey bullet, my uncle use to kill moose with one and a lot of deer, a little light in my mind. Stay with in 50 yards should be ok! Dan
May 30, 2009
JonnyM93I would have to agree with David i wouldn't take that risk using the 44-40 i would use a 300win or bigger, I just look at the size of the Bison and compared to water buffalo and they are close to the same size and guides say use a 300 and bigger as... moreI would have to agree with David i wouldn't take that risk using the 44-40 i would use a 300win or bigger, I just look at the size of the Bison and compared to water buffalo and they are close to the same size and guides say use a 300 and bigger as well. If you know you can kill a Bison with your 44-40 at close range go and have a go but, but i would use somehting bigger.