The Misadventures of Rance and Dave

  • Three or four elk seasons ago, I guided Dave Brucken and Dr. Rance Gamblin on an Idaho archery elk hunt. Dave works for the Rocky Mountain Elk Foundation and wrote a story about our little adventure that was later published in their Bugle Magazine. He and I have stayed in touch and he has given me permission to post his story here. Enjoy.
    By Dave Brucken

    With apologies to Charles Dickens, it was the best of hunts, it was the worst of hunts. Dr. Rance Gamblin, Akron chapter chair, would be my hunting partner on one of the hardest, strangest hunts I've ever had.

    Day One (Friday) After barely escaping a potentially disastrous flight change by Delta, we arrived at the Cincinnati airport with time to spare. The Ohio airport isn't even in Ohio, but rather in Kentucky, and only added to the list of strange occurrences to this hunt.

    Arriving in Hailey, Idaho, we were met by our host and outfitter, George Peter. At forty two, fit, handsome, he was the typical image of an outdoorsman. An hour and half later, we were at Trapper's Inn, our lodge and headquarters for the hunt. After the first of many delicious meals by cook Gail, we met our guides Travis and Tyler, shot our bows, drank a little Jameson and Jack Daniels, and retired to our log cabin for the night, totally oblivious to the disasters that would befall us the next few days.

    Day Two (Saturday) Awaking to the smell of hot coffee brought to us by Travis, Rance and I arose at five AM and partook of a fantastic breakfast in the lodge before loading up in a pick up and heading for Bear Creek, some forty five minutes away. Once off the public roads, we traversed creeks and rocky trails by four wheel drive, until finally arriving at our destination: which I later named hell.

    Other than a three hour late morning lunch and rest, we walked on the sides of steep rocky slopes from six AM until almost ten PM, looking for the elusive elk, finding none. The landscape was extremely harsh and unforgiving, and if you failed to plant your feet before shifting your weight, the mountain gleefully, almost sadistically caused you to slide several unsettling feet before grabbing onto a sagebrush or jutting rock. Being quiet and sneaking up on the game was out of the question. We would see no elk, we would hear no bugling, we would find little sign, despite our efforts and hours spent hiking over the roughest, slipperiest terrain imaginable.

    Travis and I split up from Tyler and Rance, and we explored yet another hillside. A light rain blew in, and when I was about ready to concede defeat, Travis spotted a very nice muley buck some 500 yards below us. As the intensity of the rain increased, we fought nearly unnavigable shale, thick sagebrush, and rock slides, in a foolish attempt to stalk the big buck. I wanted to stop and photograph a rainbow, but was too tired to retrieve my camera from the backpack. Two hours later, about 7 PM. we gave up and headed for the truck. About this time I was thinking, where's the helicopter?

    At over 10,000 feet elevation, I was already done in, surrendering to my fatigue and inability to overcome the lack of sufficient oxygen needed for my "flatlander" lungs. After many excruciating hours of clinging to and crawling/sliding along the steep hillside, my feet and knees were begging me to give up, surrender, and just crawl up in a little ball and fall asleep. Or die.

    Little did I know the nightmare was just beginning.

    Day Two, continued... The walkie talkie crackled to life: "Travis, Tyler here. We're at the truck, tell me where you're coming down, and we'll meet you at the bottom." Ten minutes later, we could see the truck a mile below us, lights on in the now-darkness.

    "Twenty minutes, top,"Travis estimated, "and we'll be in the nice dry truck, heading for a hot cup of coffee and a great dinner."

    Wrong.

    I've given this a lot of thought, and I can honestly say, the next two hours were the toughest of my entire life... Read the rest of the story...
2 comments
  • bowhunterbruce1
    bowhunterbruce1 omg what a great story,this seems like this was written on just about every single one of my elk hunting adventures, including not being successful.all be it i have never used the services of a guide yet the experience's always have far out weighed the...  more
    February 3, 2009
  • GotHunts
    GotHunts thanks for the comment, and it is true that if you can't glean from the experience regardless of success, many guided hunts will be a disapointment.
    February 3, 2009