Gentleman, their rifles and hunting

  • Bunch a group of firearm enthusiasts together, and pick hunting rifles as a topic. If there are 20 of them, you will probably hear 20 different opinions. Hunting rifles are almost like religion and politics, don't start on this topic unless you know everyone agrees. It is bound to become heated at some time.

    There has been some grand stories of great hunters and the calibers they used. Tony Sanchez Arino, one of the greatest elephant hunters of all times, was a great fan of the .416 Rigby. The sectional density and unbelievable penetration of this cartridge served Tony well for many years. He also liked his .500 Jeffrey, but preferred the .416 Rigby.

    Another legend, Kilimanjaro Bell, also a great elephant hunter in own right, for many years only used his 7x57 Mauser to hunt elephant. This led people to believe that the 7x57 was the ideal caliber to hunt elephant with. The outcome was that several hunters were killed or seriously injured. Kilimanjaro Bell once said :- 'When hunting elephant, and you are 15 yards away from it when you take the shot, you are probably 15 yards too far away.' This explained how he got to be so successful hunting elephant with his trusted 7x57. He was a great believer in excellent shot placement, and believed that on elephant this could only be achieved by getting up close and personal with the target.

    The truth is that calibers are there to provide hunters with the choice of what they want to use, and the fact that certain hunters shoot better with certain calibers. In South Africa the 30-06 Springfield is immensely popular. We also have a hunting rifle national shooting championship, sponsored by PMP, called the ProAmm Championship. In this shooting competition the 30-06 Springfield does not do well, as the best grouping over a 100m distance ever achieved was about 11mm. The .308 Winchester, on the other hand, outperforms any other caliber, with 3-shot groupings of as small as 3,5mm. At one stage the nature conservation authority in the Limpopo Province conducted a research project in order to determine what caliber was responsible for the most clean kills, and on the other end of the spectrum, which caliber was responsible for the most wounded animals. This was only for plains game. The outcome was much the same as the results in the ProAmm competition. Percentage wise the 30-06 Springfield was responsible for more wounded animals than any other caliber normally used for plains game hunting by South African hunters. The .308 Winchester again came out tops.

    Surprisingly the small 6mm .243 Winchester ranked under the top 3 rifles for plains game with the .308 Win tops, .300WM in second, with the .243 Win very close on its heels. From second to sixth there was very little to choose between the calibers. 4th place was taken up by the .270, 5th by the 7x57 Mauser, and sixth the .303 British. Magnum calibers (9.3x62/.375 H&H Mag and up) was not taken into consideration,

    Personally I do not own a .308Win, but I have a great affinity to this caliber, and it is on my wishlist to buy one. It can be successfully used on plains game up to the size of eland, and the astounding accuracy of this caliber just provides the necessary confidence in the caliber, resulting in a more confident hunter.

    As a very good alrounder, the 9.3x62 Mauser and .375 H&H Mag must rate about equal. Both calibers have fairly mild recoils, and will effectively kill any of Afric'a large game. As a PH, when hunting big game with a client, it is always comforting when the client carries a .416 Rigby. The excellent penetration of this caliber will provide clean kills every time when a good shot has been made. However, when you are facing a wounded buffalo or elephant on the charge the .416 Rigby will not provide the necessary knockdown value. Then I would prefer to have a .458 WM nestling against my shoulder. Some PH's prefer the .458 Lott. There is very little to pick between the two when it comes to knockdown value, but the .458 Lott has a recoil that could make you flinch. To me personally the difference in recoil between the two is great enough to prefer the .458 WM. Some guys disagree, and claim that the .458 Lott does not have such a bad recoil.

    At the end, having all things said and done, it is still up to the hunter to make the decision which caliber suits him/her best. But one thing that I agree with, is a statement somewhere on this website that says we have too many calibers. Worst case scenario we should not have more than 15 calibers, but 10 would be closer to the ideal number.
1 comment
  • enysse
    enysse Wyominghunter said he's tired of all the new cartridges they were trying to sell at the SCI show at Reno. I agreed they are way to many cartridges out there. My good friend thinks people are going to load the wrong bullet in the gun...because they are so...  more
    April 9, 2009